When Advice Becomes a Cage
We live in a world where advice is everywhere. Friends, family, coworkers, strangers on the internet — all ready to tell you what you should do, how you should live, and who you should be. Most of the time, it’s wrapped in good intentions. They care, they’ve been through something similar, and they want to spare you from making the “wrong” choice.
But here’s the hidden truth: advice is never neutral. It is always colored by the giver’s own experiences, beliefs, fears, and desires. When someone tells you what they think is best for you, they are really saying, “This is what I would do if I were you.” But they are not you.
The Problem with Borrowed Maps
Every life is a journey, and each of us is walking a path no one else has ever walked before. Our map is drawn with the ink of our own experiences, shaped by lessons we’ve yet to learn. When we take someone else’s advice without question, it’s like borrowing a map made for a completely different landscape. It might have beautiful routes and wise markers, but it could also lead you straight into terrain that isn’t yours to travel.
Sometimes the advice-giver is so sure of themselves that their words carry the weight of authority. You may feel pressured to follow their lead, even when your intuition whispers a different way. And so, you take steps in the wrong direction — not because you were lost, but because you listened to a voice louder than your own.
Why People Can’t Help Themselves
- People give unsolicited advice for many reasons:
- They’ve been through something similar and want to spare you the pain they felt.
- They’re projecting their own regrets or unfulfilled dreams.
- They’re uncomfortable watching you struggle or make a choice they wouldn’t.
- They genuinely believe they know what’s best.
It’s almost always well-meaning. But “meaning well” doesn’t guarantee that the advice is right for you.
The Art of Listening Without Losing Yourself
There’s a difference between listening to advice and living by it. You can receive someone’s words with gratitude, filter them through your own discernment, and still choose your own way. This doesn’t make you stubborn or ungrateful — it makes you the author of your life.
Think of advice as a buffet table. You take what nourishes you, and you leave what doesn’t suit your taste. You don’t have to eat everything just because it was offered.
Your Path, Your Lessons
No one else can walk your path for you. No one else can learn your lessons, bear your burdens, or savor your victories. Advice can guide you, but it should never dictate you. Sometimes the most valuable growth comes from making your own mistakes — because those “mistakes” are often just stepping stones in disguise.
The next time someone tells you what you should do, pause. Thank them for their care. Weigh their words against your own values and inner knowing. And then, if necessary, set them down gently and keep walking in the direction your soul points to.
After all, you weren’t put here to live someone else’s life.
How I see it
-
Intent matters, but so does delivery. People often think they’re being helpful, but they skip the step of asking, “Do you want my advice, or do you just want me to listen?”
-
Advice is never truly universal. What worked beautifully for them might be a disaster for you.
-
Unsolicited advice can be a mirror. Sometimes their suggestions reveal more about them — their fears, beliefs, and patterns — than about what’s truly right for you.
How to handle well-meaning advice without tension
- Acknowledge the intent first.
Even if you disagree, a simple, “I appreciate you caring enough to share that” goes a long way. - Set boundaries gracefully.
You can say, “That’s an interesting perspective. I’m taking a different approach, but I’ll keep it in mind.” This keeps the peace without agreeing to follow it. - Filter, don’t absorb.
Imagine advice as packages left at your doorstep. You can open the ones that seem useful and leave the rest outside. - Use curiosity to deflect pressure.
If you don’t want to argue, you can ask, “That’s how you’d do it—what made that work for you?” This shifts the focus onto them instead of your choices. - Stay rooted in your own path.
The more clear you are on your goals and values, the less sway outside opinions will have.
